Everybody seems to have hopped on the chubby stick train, and NYC has release their version with the City Proof Twistable Intense Lip Color ($2.99), a super creamy pencil lip balm.
Highly pigmented, it comes in 12 colors and may be my favorite chubby stick yet. Many of the other balms are relatively sheer, but NYC’s version truly gives lips a punch of color. It’s not quite as thick as a lipstick, but it applies smoothly and coats lips evenly while being relatively long-lasting. My must-have shades? South Ferry Berry, Canal St Coral, and Ballroom Bluch.
Perfect hues for a bright, summery lip!